Electoral contortions over gerrymandering

Re “Did Democrats lock themselves out of the House?” Current, Oct. 15

Tony Quinn’s admonishment of Democratic leaders for gerrymandering safe seats tells only part of the story. In this era of red-versus-blue America, voters have been self-selecting into partisan residential enclaves -- liberals dominate in cities, conservatives in rural areas. It has become extremely difficult to create competitive districts in California unless you draw contorted lines that, for example, would begin near downtown Los Angeles and stretch eastward into San Bernardino and Riverside counties. But those districts not only would look ridiculous, they would produce worse representation, particularly for minority voters. Even an independent redistricting commission cannot solve this dilemma. It is time to try alternatives beyond winner-take-all elections that will give California better government for the 21st century.

STEVEN HILL

Director, Political Reform Program

New America Foundation

San Francisco

*

Re “To Invade GOP Strongholds, Tap Bay Area,” Oct. 14

I must say I was stopped in mid-sentence as I digested Rep. John T. Doolittle (R-Roseville) complaining of the “concerted effort to nationalize the elections,” when he was the co-beneficiary of President Bush’s fundraiser garnering more than $1 million. When did Bush become the local Granite Bay celebrity who could fill a banquet room? Frankly, if you declare yourself a candidate of a national party, when isn’t the election a referendum on the entire package, especially if you rabidly follow a party line even at the expense of your district, state, country or conscience?

LENNY BRONSTEIN

Santa Monica